Past winners
2023
Best overall
Pazzi Pizzeria
Piaggio
MOST POPULAR
Actually Pretty Good
Picante Pie
MOST INNOVATIVE
Cravings Market Restaurant & Cravings Bistro
Quack & Berry
THE BAKER AWARD
The Dandy Brewing Company
Bigfoot Dominator
2022
Best overall
Pizza Bob’s Classic Pie
Bánh Mìzza
MOST POPULAR
Nick’s Steakhouse & Pizza
The Grill Master
MOST INNOVATIVE
Portland Street Pizza
Caesar Pizza
THE BAKER AWARD
Actually Pretty Good
JJ’s World Famous Butter Chicken Pizza
2021
THIN CRUST
Actually Pretty Good
Hot Fried Chicken
THICK CRUST
Nick’s Steakhouse & Pizza
The Kardiakafti
OUT-OF-THE-BOX
Black Sheep
Margherita in Pasta Sfoglia
THE BAKER AWARD
Nick’s Steakhouse & Pizza
2020
THIN CRUST
Pig and Duke Downtown
Grilled Flatbread
THICK CRUST
Nick’s Steakhouse & Pizza
The Morning Glory
OUT-OF-THE-BOX
Pig and Duke Connaught
Pizza Quesadilla
THE BAKER AWARD
Tops Pizza and Steakhouse
2019
THIN CRUST
Scarpetta
The Loaded Pig
THICK CRUST
Nick’s Steakhouse & Pizza
The Diavolo
OUT-OF-THE-BOX
Ollia Macarons & Tea
Coconut Raspberry Pomegranate White Chocolate Macaron-izza
THE BAKER AWARD
Nick’s Steakhouse
2018
THIN CRUST
Scarpetta
Triple pig
THICK CRUST
Windsor Pizza Co.
The Nacho Pizza
OUT-OF-THE-BOX
Ollia Macarons & Tea
Double Chocolate Salted Caramel Pretzel Macaron-izza
THE BAKER AWARD
Beer Revolution
2017
THIN CRUST
Best Crust: The Garage
Out-Of-The-Box: Spot On
Best Overall: Windsor Pizza
THICK CRUST
Best Crust: Posto Pizzeria
Out-Of-The-Box: The Still
Best Overall: Cibo
UNIQUE
Best Crust: Grate & Barrel
Out-Of-The-Box: Avatara
Best Overall: Madison's 1212
2016
THIN CRUST
500 Cucina
Full Circle Pizza
Oyster Bar
THICK CRUST
Windsor Pizza Co.
Matador Pizza & Steakhouse
GLUTEN FREE
YYC Earth Cravings
500 Cucina
UNIQUE
Fast-lane Pizza
Ollia Macarons & Tea
2015
THIN CRUST
500 Cucina
Brooklyn Pizzeria
THICK CRUST
Gordo's Pizza
The Garrison Pub
GLUTEN FREE
Famoso Neapolitan Pizzeria
Next Door Wine
UNIQUE
Beer Revolution
NU Burger Sushi Bar
2014
THIN CRUST
500 Cucina
Bocce
Toscana Italian Grill
THICK CRUST
Gordo's Pizza
Christo's Greek Restaurant
UNIQUE
Bensonhurst Pizza Co.
Pizza Master Fusion